compareelectronic
Question  ·  PC components

External SSD or HDD?

An external SSD is faster and more portable; a hard drive gives cheaper bulk storage. Compare transfer maths, capacity, durability and UK prices.

By , Founder and Editor
Published
On this page

At a glance

Portable work and speed

The Crucial X9 SSD gives up to 1,050MB/s and costs £199.99.
Crucial X9 2TB

Low-cost bulk storage

The Seagate hard drive saves £113.00 at the same 2TB capacity.
Seagate Portable 2TB (STGX2000400)

Choose an external SSD for moving active work, frequent transfers or a drive carried every day. Choose an external hard drive for a large, mostly stationary library or an inexpensive backup copy. In Amazon UK's 12 November 2026 listing snapshot, the 2TB Crucial X9 external SSD was £199.99 and the 2TB Seagate Portable HDD was £86.99. Both advertise 2TB, but the SSD costs £113.00 more.

Storage should be matched to the job, not ranked by speed alone. An SSD is compact and has no moving parts; an HDD trades speed and impact tolerance for lower purchase cost per terabyte. Neither is a substitute for a second copy of important files. For internal game storage, see our SSD versus hard drive gaming explainer and the external hard drive shortlist.

How much faster is an external SSD?

For the specific examples here, Crucial rates its X9 at up to 1,050MB/s read and the Seagate Portable listing gives the HDD up to 120MB/s. Dividing the maximum quoted rates gives an 8.75-fold difference, but this is a comparison of advertised peaks and not a controlled benchmark. Real transfer speeds depend on USB generation, cable, host controller, thermal conditions and whether the work involves large files or many small ones.

A simple time model shows why a fast SSD helps with a large video file. At the quoted maxima, moving 100GB at 1,000MB/s takes about 100 seconds; at 120MB/s, it takes about 833 seconds, or nearly 14 minutes. That arithmetic assumes decimal gigabytes, a continuous transfer at the exact advertised rate and no overhead. Actual transfers take longer, and the Crucial's 1,050MB/s maximum is not guaranteed sustained performance. The estimate illustrates the scale, not a product test.

The connection can cap either drive. The Crucial X9 uses USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10Gbps, while the Seagate Portable listing uses USB 3.2 Gen 1 at 5Gbps. A 5Gbps port, older cable or hub can constrain an SSD well below its quoted maximum. Check the computer's port specification and use the supplied or appropriately rated cable. A Type-C connector shape alone does not prove the port supports 10Gbps.

Cost and maximum-rate comparison, Amazon UK snapshot 12 November 2026
DriveAdvertised capacityListing pricePrice per TBQuoted peak read
Crucial X9 SSD2TB£199.99£100.00Up to 1,050MB/s
Seagate Portable HDD2TB£86.99£43.50Up to 120MB/s
Price differenceSame stated capacity£113.00£56.50/TBAbout 8.75x quoted rate

The per-terabyte figures divide each listing price by its 2TB advertised capacity. Decimal units are used so the comparison uses the drive makers' labels. Formatted usable space is lower, and a capacity formatted for one operating system may need reformatting for another.

Which drive is better for travel and backups?

An SSD is usually the more practical travelling drive because it is smaller, lighter and has no rotating platters. Crucial's X9 product flyer lists a 2m drop-resistance claim and the model weighs about 32g. A mechanical portable drive needs more care when powered because a shock can interrupt moving parts. Neither product should be treated as rugged unless its exact model rating covers the real situation.

For backups, an HDD's lower price can make a second copy affordable. A 2TB Seagate at £86.99 leaves £113.00 compared with the X9, enough to buy another backup device in some price ranges. But a single drive kept beside the PC is vulnerable to theft, fire, accidental deletion and ransomware. A useful home plan has at least two copies on separate media, with one copy disconnected or stored elsewhere. A cloud copy can complement a local drive for irreplaceable files.

Use an SSD when files are opened and rewritten often, carried between locations, or copied under time pressure. Use an HDD when data is written occasionally and read back later, such as a photo archive or computer backup that is not used every day. If the drive is a working archive, check that it spins down or disconnects safely, and schedule a restore check. A backup that has never been tested may not be readable when needed.

Radar  ·  0-100 scores

  • Crucial X9 2TB
  • Seagate Portable 2TB (STGX2000400)

Which external drive should you buy?

The Crucial X9 2TB is the better fit for active files and portable work. It is much faster on paper, weighs less and its published drop rating adds reassurance for travel. At £199.99 on Amazon UK in November 2026, it costs more than twice as much as the Seagate drive. That premium is easiest to justify when the drive is used often enough for faster transfers to matter.

Crucial X9 2TB

Connection

USB-C 3.2 Gen 2

Maximum read

1050 MB/s

Price

Compare price

Crucial X9 2TB specifications
  • capacity tb: 2
  • form factor: Portable SSD
  • interface: USB-C 3.2 Gen 2
  • interface gbps: 10
  • read mb s: 1050
  • ip rating water: 0
  • drop m: 2
  • weight g: 32

Crucial X9 2TB: pros and cons

Up to 1,050MB/s listed read speed
Compact solid-state design for everyday travel
2TB capacity for active project files
£113.00 more than the same-capacity HDD in this snapshot
Real speed depends on the host port and workload
Drop rating does not remove the need for a backup

Where to buy

Check price

The Seagate Portable 2TB is the value choice for a backup copy or less frequently used media. Its Amazon UK listing was £86.99 at the time of writing (November 2026). The lower cost per terabyte lets a buyer keep more data offline for the same budget, but the hard drive takes longer to transfer large files and needs more careful handling. For other size options, see the external hard drive buying guide.

Seagate Portable 2TB (STGX2000400)

Connection

USB 3.0

Capacity

2TB

Price

Compare price

Seagate Portable 2TB specifications
  • capacity tb: 2
  • form factor: 2.5-inch
  • interface: USB 3.0
  • interface gbps: 5
  • warranty years: 2
  • rescue years: 2
  • ip rating water: 0
  • drop m: 0

Seagate Portable 2TB: pros and cons

Lower upfront cost and price per terabyte
Practical for bulk backup and media storage
USB connection works with many computers
Slower access and file transfers than an SSD
Contains mechanical parts that need careful handling
A single backup drive is not a complete backup plan

Where to buy

Check price

Should you buy an external SSD or HDD?

Buy an external SSD when frequent transfer time and portability are worth paying for. Buy an external hard drive when the priority is inexpensive capacity for archives or a second backup. The products compared here both advertise 2TB, but the Seagate costs £113.00 less and the Crucial quotes an 8.75-fold higher peak read rate. Use the dated prices and theoretical transfer comparison as a guide, not a guarantee of real speeds.

Read the external hard drive shortlist, the CMR and SMR backup explainer and the internal SSD generation comparison before settling on a storage setup.

Frequently asked questions

Is an external SSD better than a hard drive?

An external SSD is better for active files, portable work and fast transfers; a portable hard drive is better for low-cost bulk storage. A Crucial X9 2TB was £199.99 on Amazon UK on 12 November 2026, while a Seagate Portable 2TB was £86.99. The HDD saves £113.00 but is slower and contains moving parts.

Is an external hard drive good for backups?

Yes, an external hard drive can provide an affordable backup copy if it is disconnected after the backup and stored safely. One drive alone is not a complete backup plan: theft, damage, ransomware or a failed disk can remove the only copy. Keep another copy on a separate device or service for important files.

How fast is a portable SSD?

A portable SSD's real transfer rate depends on the SSD, USB port, cable, computer and file pattern. Crucial rates the X9 up to 1,050MB/s, while the USB 3.2 Gen 1 Seagate HDD listing specifies up to 120MB/s. These manufacturer or listing maximums are not guaranteed sustained speeds in every host.

Can an external SSD survive a drop?

Solid-state storage has no spinning platters or moving read heads, so it can tolerate knocks better than a mechanical drive in general. That does not make every SSD drop-proof. Check the exact model's tested drop rating and keep a backup, because a damaged connector, controller or flash cells can still make data inaccessible.

Which is cheaper per terabyte?

In the Amazon UK snapshot dated 12 November 2026, the Seagate Portable 2TB cost £43.50 per advertised TB and the Crucial X9 2TB cost about £100 per TB. The hard drive therefore cost £113.00 less at the same advertised capacity. The SSD's speed and compactness explain part of the premium.

Can I use an external drive with a console?

Many consoles accept USB storage for media or game storage, but support depends on console generation and the type of games. Some systems allow older titles to run from USB while requiring internal high-speed storage for current-generation games. Check the console maker's current compatibility guide before buying a drive for that purpose.